|
| E-mail Us | ||
| Speech for the C.H.A.M.P. Conference 2002, Reno, Nevada |
Stubby in World War
I
Stubby was a stray
brown and white ABPT puppy when Private John Conroy picked him up in 1917. He
was destined to become the most decorated war dog in
Stubby reached the
trenches in February 1918 in the midst of a horrific battle. Although the dog
was never trained to cope with such nightmarish conditions, he calmly endured a
mounting barrage of shelling. Stubby's caretakers were
amazed by his cool under fire, and absolutely stunned
when he ventured out into no man’s land to seek out and comfort wounded soldiers
caught in the crossfire. News of the little dog's heroism and fidelity reached
the French
Stubby carried
messages under fire, stood sentry duty, helped paramedics find the wounded, and
gave early warning of deadly gas attacks. When Stubby found and helped capture a
German spy who was mapping a layout of the Allied trenches, he was awarded the
honorary rank of Sergeant. Seriously wounded by shrapnel, he was sent to the Red
Cross hospital for surgery just like any other soldier. Once recovered, the
gutsy pit bull returned to his regiment and continued to serve until
Upon his return to
the
Stubby spent his
final years with John Conroy the beloved soldier who had rescued him. He died of
old age in 1926.
But Stubby was not
the first American pit bull terrier to help
The 102nd
Pennsylvania Infantry claimed that their beloved Civil War mascot-a
brown-and-white pit bull named Jack-understood bugle calls and obeyed only the
men of his regiment. Severely wounded in battle, he recovered, only to be
captured by the South. So loved and honored was Jack, he was exchanged at Belle
Isle for a Confederate soldier.
Sallie, the little
brindle mascot and comrade of the 11th Pennsylvania Volunteers,
refused to leave the wounded of her regiment during the three-day stand at
The American pit
bull terrier was chosen as
Known as the
Staffordshire Terrier in his native
By the close of the
18th Century however, public consciousness rebelled at these appalling displays
of cruelty. Early in the 19th Century, Parliament banned animal baiting.
But Englishmen
could not do without blood sport. They tried a new tack by forcing their
bulldogs to fight other dogs. As time went on, dog fighters sought a lighter,
more athletic animal. To this end, the bulldog was often crossed with the
English black-and-tan terrier. So, the pit bull is, after all, just a “bull dog”
and a “terrier.” Strong, agile and very intelligent, these crossbred dogs were,
by nature, extremely loyal to their masters. Fiercely competitive with other
dogs in the fighting ring, they were stable and trustworthy with people of all
ages. Because it was necessary for handlers to be able to separate dogs in the
pit, dogs displaying aggression toward humans were not serviceable and were
quickly culled, leaving a breed characterized by human friendliness and
stability. “Pit bulls” often lived as family members and their reliability with
children earned them the nickname "nursemaid's dog" or "nanny dog". Soon after
arrival in the
Petey, pit bull mascot of "Our
Gang", was beloved by children and adults alike. Tales of American pit bull
terriers by American writers abound: John Steinbeck wrote about Jigg; James Thurber wrote about Rex; Mark Twain about Andrew
Jackson; Sir Walter Scott eulogized his beloved bull and terrier Wasp.
Advertising
featuring the pit bull sprang up: Nipper, RCA’S black-and-white pit bull dog,
has for generations listened to “His Master’s Voice”; Tige (TIE) sold Buster Brown shoes; a young boy and his pit
bull sold Levi's jeans; and even the U.S. Postal Service showcased the breed
with a stamp featuring Helen Keller with her pit bull at her feet. Then, in
World War II, a US Marine and his American Pit Bull Terrier where once again the
defenders of Old Glory. The American pit bull terrier was still the dog of
The Pit Bull
Today
What
happened?
In the 1980’s when
the media reported on Dog Fighting, replete with the myths of the locking jaws
and the bite of a thousand pounds pressure, they made the dog the villain of the
piece, RATHER THAN THE PEOPLE WHO PLACED THE DOGS IN THE PIT AND THOSE WHO
WAGERED ON THE OUTCOME. A MEDIA
MONSTER WAS BORN AND HIS NAME WAS….’PITBULL’. That legend made the dog
attractive to the street bully, pick-up fighter, drug dealer, and gang member.
These delinquents, attracted by that image, exploited the loyalty, courage, and
trainability of the breed. The pit
bull now had a new master, and in ever-increasing numbers, he was mis-bred, mis-treated, mis-directed, abused and then cast off…fueling the media
fire. These victims and throwaways, not
the multitude of pit bulls living harmoniously at home, form the basis of the
public perception of the American pit bull terrier, and they are flooding our
shelters.
TODAY THE AMERICAN
PIT BULL TERRIER IS A BREED UNDER SEIGE.
He, along with three other breeds and a legion of look-alikes have been
lumped together as a media manufactured, irresponsible, criminal owner fostered,
bad dog monster called “PIT BULL”.
NOT A BREED AT ALL, JUST A LABEL BASED LOOSELY ON SIMILARITIES IN
APPEARANCE
The
image of the APBT as a natural human aggressor is attention grabbing, but it is
also false and destructive. You will hear about
“Pit Bulls” featured in the dog bite statistics, BUT WHAT THOSE WHO REPORT THOSE
STATISTICS DON’T TELL YOU IS WHAT THE VERY GROUPS CHARGED WITH GATHERING THE
INFORMATION HAVE CONCLUDED.
The June 2001
comprehensive report from the Task Force on Canine Aggression and Human Canine
Interactions contained this paragraph. Please, LISTEN CAREFULLY …THIS IS A
DIRECT QUOTE:
“An often asked question is what breed or
breeds of dogs are most dangerous. This inquiry can be prompted by a serious
attack by a specific dog, or it may be the result of media driven portrayals of
a specific breed as dangerous. Although this is a common concern, singling out 1
or 2 breeds for control can result in a false sense of accomplishment. Doing so ignores the true scope of the
problem and will not result in a responsible approach to protecting a
community’s citizens. DOG BITE
STATISTICS ARE NOT REALLY STATISTICS, AND THEY DO NOT GIVE AN ACCURATE PICTURE
OF DOGS THAT BITE.” END OF QUOTE.
The public, unaware
that society’s criminal element has perverted a noble character, brands the APBT
the criminal, assigning blame to the victim who is only anxious to please its
master, while the responsible moral agent goes free. Be assured that this criminal element
will simply choose another breed, if the pit bull is not
available.
Although he may
have a propensity to challenge other dogs, the true American pit bull terrier is
stable and loves people. Any display of human aggression, whether stemming from
intentional mis-breeding or mis-training, is an aberration. Such dogs, even though they
are victims and be sure they are victims--, should never be placed.
Intra-species aggression, on the other hand, must be taken seriously, but is a
management and placement issue.
We must restore the
image of the American pit bull terrier.
Several American
pit bull terriers now work with U.S. Customs as drug-sniffing and bomb-sniffing
dogs. These include Popsicle, who was originally found wounded, bloody,
undernourished and near death, in a freezer on a drug dealer's back porch. Now
Popsicle makes his mark helping federal agents sniff out the kind of bad guy who
had tried to kill him.
On a U.S. Marine
Corps base in
Hundreds of APBT’s visit nursing homes, hospitals and schools as
certified therapy dogs. Many are agility, obedience, and weight-pull champions.
The honor of becoming
All across
Then there is Kris
Crawford, an Animal Farm Foundation matching grant program recipient, and her
three search-and-rescue pit bulls.
Say “hello” to Kris, here today with Dakota and Tahoe. Dakota began her
life as a bait dog, and Tahoe was found in a dumpster. Today they are members of
the California Rescue Dog Association.
You can get
acquainted with them at our booth, and at the search and rescue workshop
tomorrow. Not only do they perform
search and rescue missions, Kris and her pit bulls offer safety and educational
programs for children and adults.
Their work has changed perceptions of the pit bull terrier for those they
have rescued, for the reporters who have written about them, and for the
multitude of readers of those stories.
As of December of
2001, 82.7% of APBTs passed the American Temperament
Test – a slightly higher percentage than that achieved by the golden retriever.
Sound dogs, whatever the breed, with responsible owners, make good companions.
Today we ask you to protect this dog from cruelty and return him to an honorable
position in American society.
How can you help? Remember, the dogs you don’t help are going
somewhere. And the owners you don’t
advise will do
something.
What can
happen?
1.
The dogs may be
inhumanely euthanized by an inferior
facility.
2.
They may be taken in,
but adopted out unspayed or unneutered, without proper evaluation and without high-bar
adopter standards.
3.
They may be warehoused,
with no regard to their needs and no consideration for the quality of their
lives, creating a negative image of the breed as well as the shelter that houses
them.
4.
They may be abandoned by
their owners to run loose, unfed, unspayed, unneutered. They may be locked away
without protection, food or water.
They may be tied up and left at the mercy of the elements and man. They may be beaten, shot, cut or burned
alive.
5.
They may fall into the
hands of criminals, to be tortured, forced to guard or attack, forced to fight,
or used for bait.
Fad breed and special
needs dogs pose a unique challenge for the no-kill community. The breeds may change, but the problems
of overpopulation, irresponsible and abusive owners and breeders will
remain. Pit Bulls when
appropriately selected and evaluated, can be responsibly re-homed, and are
entitled to the same humane consideration as any other dog.
It seems that no one
group or individual can design a policy acceptable to all. Having said that, the
problem is not going to go away.
While the same solution will never be acceptable to everyone, some soul
searching may be in order before policies are put into action. For those who have already initiated a
program, it is never a bad thing to examine the system in place to ascertain its
short- and long-term effects on the animals. Ultimately, it’s all about the
animals. And if it’s not, it should
be.
Whatever your current
policies, and however limited your resources, we must all work to reduce the
numbers and to restore the dog’s image.
As we work together on this endeavor, however long it takes and however
difficult the task may seem, we must nevertheless be uncompromising in our
determination to protect these dogs from cruelty and to spare them further
suffering. Animal Farm Foundation has some suggestions that will make you a
partner in the solution.
1.
Begin by making “humble”
decisions regarding your abilities and mission. Examine your policies with an honest
assessment of your financial, managerial, and professional capacities. What can you do yourself? What must you refer to
others?
2.
If you are unable to
take pit bulls in or adopt them out, explain your policy without further
victimizing the dogs, who are already victims, and without compromising the
efforts of your fellow shelters. If
those of us closest to the animals characterize a breed as innately vicious and
dangerous, not only do we perpetrate an untruth, we inadvertently create demand
for such a dog among those who are the least responsible dog owners. Also, we make it more difficult for
fellow shelters that are working to rehome these dogs. On the other hand, when we explain our
policies in terms of the severe overpopulation, the shortage of responsible
homes, the current unavailability of appropriate long-term sanctuary, the
shortage of funds, and our concern for the safety of the dogs, rather than
furthering a negative image, we have honestly described the problem, and have
become part of the solution.
3.
However, “We don’t take pit bulls. We’re
full. We can’t help,” are not
useful responses to people who have found a dog, or who have one they can no
longer keep, or who are in need of training help. You may well be exposing that
dog to the grim realities I just showed you. Instead, refer those you can’t help to
Pit Bull Rescue Central, an extensive nationwide, internet resource, where
education meets rescue. PBRC may
help the people who call you find the resources they need in your area. In your
packets you will find stickers you can post to remind staff and volunteers to
refer callers to http://www.pbrc.net/, when
they themselves can’t help.
4.
Even if you don’t have a
pit bull adoption program, you can help restore their image and protect them
from cruelty. Be a source of accurate public information and positive
press. For example, make the Task Force on Canine Aggression and
Human-Canine Interactions Community Approach to Dog Bite Prevention Report
available to community leaders, animal control agencies, and local media. Help
them understand that breed-specific legislation is not a solution. For further
information on this important report, visit the website whose address can be
found on your resources sheet. Use Pit Bull Press to find up-to-date positive
stories. Feature a local pit bull
hero in your newsletter, publish Animal Farm Foundation’s popular history of the
breed, or borrow our historic postcard exhibit.
5.
Even if you don’t have a
pit bull adoption program you can be an essential part of the solution by
creating or expanding low-cost, free, or incentivized
pit bull and pit bull mix spay/neuter programs. I want to commend to you the “We
Pay to Spay” Program developed by the Sacramento SPCA. I want to thank Mike Winters, Suzanne
Somers, Terry Klippert and the many volunteers, vets,
vet techs, and shelter workers who have made this program such a success. And especially Lynn Madison for making
the details of this program available to us today. We have reprinted the template of their
program, and have included a copy in your packet. “We Pay to Spay” offers a $20.00
incentive for the spaying or neutering of any pit bull or pit bull mix. SSPCA is reaching people who would not
spay or neuter, or otherwise prevent their dogs from breeding. Sacramento SPCA has, in the first two
years, spayed or neutered 1000 dogs. Consider the multiplier effect and the
number of dogs that will never come to a shelter because those 1000 dogs were
neutered. I believe their efforts
will count for tens of thousands of “saves,” animals never brought into a life
of suffering. Animals you will
never have to pay to shelter. So long as he remains a fad breed, low-cost, free,
or incentivized breed-specific
spay/neuter is an essential part of any humane agency’s public service. And I
think, after you have looked at the program developed in Sacramento, you will
agree that because it is so simple, it can begin on a very small scale, can be
implemented with or without an on-site spay-neuter clinic and, thus, is within
everyone’s reach. It will reduce the numbers, and restore the dog’s image. In
aid of these purposes, beginning in 2003, we will allocate $50,000 each year for
awards and grants for innovative, high-performance, reproducible pit bull and
pit bull mix spay-neuter programs that reach owners who would not otherwise spay
and neuter their dogs, and that are presented in a manner that helps to restore
the image of the breed. We expect to post guidelines for these awards and grants
on our web site in January 2003. I want to take this opportunity today to
announce that we have just made a special award, of $10,000, to the Sacramento
SPCA for their “We pay to Spay” program.
I hope many among you will follow their lead and initiate a similar or
even more effective program in your facility.
6.
We also believe in and
support pit bull adoption programs.
If you do adopt out pit bulls, we hope they will be True Ambassadors and
that they will be placed in high-bar homes. Begin a True Ambassador Program in
your shelter – one dog at a time.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program chooses its
candidates with the help of persons knowledgeable about the virtues and
challenges of the breed. Please refer to the advice from Diane Jessup given in
our handout. Dr. Amy Marder will be showing you how to
create a thorough, useful intake history. A template has been provided for you
in your packet. Dr. Marder will also outline the evaluation process that has
made her programs a success.
A TRUE
AMBASSADOR program insures that the population does not exceed your capacity to
house and exercise these dogs for the time it will take to secure responsible
homes.
Housing the APBT, as with any high-energy,
active-minded breed, provides a challenge for the sheltering community. A dog
with a sound mind and constitution will stay sound, if activities are provided
to stimulate his mind, exercise his body, and satisfy his people-loving and
needing nature. A
dog that might do very well when home-placed or in foster care, may not do well
when kenneled for an extended time. Housing is best in low-stress
areas. Generous inside-outside
kennels that also provide some privacy and protection from the other residents
are ideal. Resting benches or even just blankets are important for these
“creature comfort” dogs. A softly played radio will help, as well. While
confined to an inside kennel, activity toys (Kongs, Buster cubes, and Galileo
chews) give the dogs something to do. You can even make dinner a mentally
stimulating event by putting it inside a Kong. Check out the Kong Seconds Program in
our packet. Attend Corinne Dowling’s presentation this afternoon for excellent
long-term kenneling advice. Corinne’s Give-A-Dog-Bone Program is another example
of the kind of program Animal Farm Foundation supports.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program spays/neuters,
immunizes, and microchips all dogs.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program has a staff and
volunteer breed education component.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program provides dogs with
human interaction, mental and physical exercise, positive motivational training,
and, when appropriate, socialization with a matched dog of the opposite sex.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program establishes and
enforces high-bar adopter criteria. It evaluates the physical home, as well as
the entire human and animal family. Animal Farm Foundation discourages placement
in homes with other dogs of the same sex and urges careful evaluation of
placements in any multiple-animal home. Intra-species aggression, if it appears
at all, may not manifest until the dog is mature. Adopters must be comfortable
and prepared to deal with both the virtues and the challenges of the breed. We
at Animal Farm Foundation want to inspire responsible, knowledgeable, ownership.
We have prepared a high-risk adopter handout that is included in your
packet. I urge you to read it and
to refer to it as a guideline. But
always keep in mind that there are exceptions, with people and dogs alike. If we in the sheltering community remain
alert to our responsibility to the dog and our potential adopters, we are able
to use guidelines effectively as a basis, not a substitute, for good judgment.
Our list is not meant to be
all-encompassing; and, though many of these concerns apply to all dogs, we have
tried to focus on those most important when screening applicants seeking fad
breed “pit bull” dogs. Remember,
these dogs are unlikely to get a second chance. A bad placement may result in
further damaging the breed’s reputation, as well as placing the dog in the grim
situations we have just seen.
When considering the
suitability of an adopter for a fad breed “pit bull,” remember the dogs from our
popular history -- Stubby, Sallie, Big Duke Six, Petey, Popsicle, Dakota -- and the breed predispositions
that made them who they are.
People-loving and
needing
Prone to intra-species
aggression
Loyal, eager to
please
Comical
Steadfast
High energy, athletic,
strong
Easily aroused, but are
highly trainable
Love/need to have “a
job”
(Soft dogs who respond
to positive training)
Possibly
protective/territorial, but they are not guard
dogs
“Gameness”
High prey
drive
High
play drive
Individual dogs may
manifest some or none of these traits, and in varying degrees and
intensities. When you consider
these predispositions in conjunction with your standard adopter evaluation and
application process, you will see how some candidates, while fine adopters for
some dogs, may be high-risk adopters for this breed. A first-time owner with the
appropriate home site should not be eliminated out of hand, but should be
matched with a dog who is lower-energy, lower prey and
play drive . . . that is, low on the scale of those traits that may be
challenging for an inexperienced owner. We suggest you consider how your
candidate “matches up” with these virtues and challenges. Remember the current climate and
prejudice, which comes with “pit bull” ownership, and determine if your
candidate will present his dog in a positive light in the community.
The following ten musts in pit bull placement will
also help eliminate high-risk candidates in favor of high-bar
owners.
1.
Insist on spay/neuter,
and implement early spay/neuter (not a deposit program).
2.
Conduct a home check in
light of the demands of the breed and the individual dog. Be certain there is a safe place for the
dog to spend his days and nights, where he can’t get out, and others can’t get
in. Require written landlord
approval for renters. Determine if the neighborhood is
high-risk.
3.
Verify an adequately
fenced yard or evidence of an alternate method of sufficient and safe
exercise.
4.
Be certain the adopter
is familiar with the breed and demonstrates an understanding of its virtues and
challenges . . . and has the resources (time, place, money) to meet them.
5.
Avoid same-sex
placements and multiple-animal households. Require a frank discussion of
dog-to-dog aggression and prey drive. Caution against “pit bulls” in dog
parks. Require that the dog be
leashed at all times in public places.
6.
Implement a vet check
with particular attention to the disposition and condition of the applicant’s
previous dogs.
7.
Require puppy obedience
class(es). Strongly recommend
obedience class(es), as well
as continuing work with all dogs.
8.
Conduct a frank
discussion of “pit bull” prejudice. The pride is worth the prejudice; but is
your applicant prepared to live with the prejudice that may come with “pit bull”
ownership: homeowner insurance discrimination; landlord discrimination;
community and media misinformation; breed-specific
legislation?
9.
Conduct a frank
discussion of children and dog safety.
(The AKC Child-safety video features a “Staffie”. Remember that, contrary to the media
image, the “pit bull” was known to generations of Americans as “the nanny dog.”)
Will your applicant work with the dog when the new baby comes? Do you feel the
applicant will be responsible for the safety of the child(ren) and the dog? Will they
provide appropriate supervision and separation? Do they have the resources to
meet the needs of all family members?
10.
Give every adopter an
information packet. Include our resource list (to be found in your handout),
which contains breed information, as well as information on pet-friendly
insurance companies and pet-friendly housing. Provide follow-up assistance and
referrals.
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program monitors the
success of each placement, and uses those successes to promote new
adoptions.
AND FINALLY….
A TRUE AMBASSADOR program gives a dog his day
when you cannot give him back his life.
GIVE A DOG HIS DAY
Perhaps
part of the reason we all have such difficulty discussing the pit bull "problem"
is the fact that we find ourselves up against a "brick wall" when it comes to
saving all of the pit bulls that are out there. There are no hard statistics,
but it is clear that pit bulls or dogs construed to be pit bulls are bred in
backyards, basements, empty buildings throughout the country. They are filling
our streets, packing our shelters. Often we have no idea where they come from -
only that they keep on coming - victims of dog fighting, drug raids, breed bans,
landlord discrimination, media assassination, intentional mis-breeding, and irresponsible ownership. As we all know, homes which can offer a
loving, supportive environment to this high-energy breed are hard to come by and
take a long time to locate, while long-term kenneling can be torture for these
people-loving dogs.
Because we
came into the field of animal rescue committed to saving lives, some facts are
hard to face. There are simply not enough acceptable homes for all of the
thrown-away pit bulls and pit bull crosses. As animal welfare personnel, our
mission is to alleviate suffering to protect from cruelty, to shelter and offer
safe haven to all companion animals without prejudice. It is important that we
honor that mission, placing true ambassadors of the breed in acceptable homes
whenever possible. But there are dogs for whom
euthanasia is the only haven from a life of cruelty. When we aren't able to
offer a pit bull his life in a new home we can, at least, offer him a small
measure of compassion and dignity as he approaches the unavoidable
end.
This
offering can take many forms. When safe to do so, it can mean taking him for a
long walk, holding him in our arms, offering him a toy, an opportunity to play
in the sunshine. If safety is a question, it can mean spending some time with
him outside his kennel, talking to him, looking into his eyes. Whatever small
contribution we can make, we must make to honor his life and soften his death.
This is the least we can offer this loyal breed who has served us so
well.
The dog
inhabits a no-man's land between human and animal. Unlike the cat, the pig, the
sheep or the horse, he cannot, if given the opportunity, take up where he left
off with Nature. Whether he came from wolves or gods, it appears the faithful
dog has always been with us functioning as companion, guardian and helper. Few
people recognize the dog for what he is - a precious gift to our species who
asks nothing more than to be allowed to accompany us always, to help us, protect
us, to share our joys and sorrows. He is our species' soul-mate.
We must never take him
for granted. He has asked only to do our bidding and live by our side. The pit
bull is our responsibility and must always be included in our circle of
compassion.
Remember. The dogs we
don’t help are going somewhere. The
owners we don’t advise will do something.
We must reduce their numbers.
We must restore their image.
We must protect them from cruelty.
We must never leave them outside our circle of
compassion.
I am pleased to
introduce Dr. Amy Marder, who is a veterinarian, an
animal behavior consultant, and Director of the behavioral program at the Animal
Rescue League of Boston. She has
been instrumental in inspiring, creating and facilitating successful pit bull
adoption programs across the country.
When she came from New York ASPCA to Animal Rescue League of Boston, the
MSSPCA was the only area shelter adopting out adult pit bull dogs. ARL did not have an adoption program,
and Boston Animal Control euthanized all but puppies.
Today, all three agencies have successful pit bull adoption programs, a
wonderful example of agencies working together. Dr. Marder is
here today to show you how she implements an intake profile, and how she
conducts an evaluation.
[Amy’s
presentation]
Click here
for Intake form
Click here for Evaluation form
CLOSING
Thank you, Dr. Marder, and everyone who took their time to be here for the
American Pit Bull Terrier.
I hope our resource
handout package will help you be a part of the solution. Additional packages can
be ordered through Animal Farm Foundation. Finally, over and above the funding I
announced earlier for innovative spay-neuter programs, Animal Farm Foundation
considers applications for other endeavors that further our mission: to restore the image of the American Pit
Bull Terrier and to protect him from discrimination and cruelty.
The pit bull is the fad
breed of today, and presents special challenges to the sheltering
community. The breed may change,
but the demands of fad breeds will continue. Remember. The dogs we don’t help are
going somewhere. The owners we
don’t advise will do something. We
must reduce their numbers. We must
restore their image. We must
protect them from cruelty. We must
never leave them outside our circle of compassion.